Treasury Inspector General of Tax Administration (TIGTA) Press Release: TIGTA Report: Despite Some Favorable Partnership Audit Trends at the IRS, the Number of No-Change Audits Is a Concern, (Jul. 20, 2012)
Click to open document in a browser
Treasury Inspector General of Tax Administration (TIGTA) press release: Partnership audits: No-change audits: Discriminant Index Function system
Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration
July 19, 2012
TIGTA - 2012-32
Contact: David Barnes
TIGTA Report: Despite Some Favorable Partnership Audit Trends at the IRS, the Number of No-Change Audits Is a Concern
WASHINGTON - Although the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is improving its systems for auditing the tax returns of business partnerships, it is closing a large number of partnership audits without recommending changes, according to a report released publicly today by the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA).
In deciding which returns to audit, the IRS strives to select those returns for which its examiners are likely to find areas of noncompliance and recommend changes to one or more items reported on the return. However, the number of audits closed with no recommended adjustments (no-change) is high among the returns selected by the Discriminant Index Function system, which uses mathematical formulas to calculate and assign a score to returns based on their audit potential.
According to the IRS, a high no-change rate means compliant taxpayers are unnecessarily burdened by audits. TIGTA initiated its audit to determine whether Small Business/Self-Employed (SB/SE) Division examiners are conducting audits of partnership tax returns in accordance with IRS policy and procedures.
TIGTA found that the IRS closed nearly 25 percent more partnership audits in Fiscal Year 2011 than in Fiscal Year 2007. While the IRS has increased the number of partnership audits, the time examiners spend on partnership audits has decreased. The average number of calendar days for audits decreased almost 11 percent, and the number of examiner hours decreased more than 15 percent, TIGTA found.
However, Fiscal Year 2011 statistics from the SB/SE Division showed that about 50 percent of the partnership returns audited were closed as a no-change. Except for a few instances, TIGTA did not find any significant quality problems during our review that would suggest how the items selected and audited on partnership returns could substantially improve the no-change rates. Examiners generally followed procedures in selecting and verifying the accuracy of items they audited on partnership returns.
SB/SE Division researchers should consider exploring partnership data files to determine whether the most productive returns are selected for audit,” said J. Russell George, Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration. “With skills in such specialized areas as statistics, operations research, economics, and computers, SB/SE Division researchers are uniquely qualified to suggest alternative audit selection methods and explore details such as evaluating whether examiners should audit more partnership returns with international features or assessing the revenue impact from partnership audits.
TIGTA recommended that, as resources become available, the Director, Research, SB/SE Division, analyze partnership data files to help identify additional productive returns for audit, including returns with international features. In their response to the report, IRS officials agreed with the recommendation and stated that the Director, Research, SB/SE Division, plans to work in collaboration with the SB/SE Division's Examination function to analyze partnership data files in order to better identify productive partnership returns for audit, including those returns with international features. As part of the return analysis, the SB/SE Division's Research function plans to consult with other IRS research units.