Showing posts with label joint returns. Show all posts
Showing posts with label joint returns. Show all posts

Monday, June 13, 2011

A Ruling on Fraud and Some Innocent Spouse Cases

Private Letter Ruling 201114005

LLC was qualified investor for purposes of claiming theft loss deduction under Rev. Proc. 2009-20 and discovery year for purposes of claiming deduction was stated year.


Cases and rulings involving fraud have an almost pornographic appeal to me. I always want some detailed descriptions in there. This ruling measured up in that regard:

In Year 4, some of Company's loans began to default. Individual A, President of Company from Year 2 until Date 6, and Individual B, chairman and CEO of Company from Year 1 until Date 6, the lead figures, concealed from investors that loans were not performing and caused Company to continue to pay interest to investors regardless of whether the underlying borrowers had made loan payments to the Account X. As a result, the Account X had insufficient funds to make payments to all of its investors, and Individuals A and B began to look for sources of money to cover the shortage in the Account X. One of the ways Individuals A and B covered the shortage was by not remitting principal payments to investors when borrowers paid off the loans. Individuals A and B made it appear as if the loans were still performing by paying the investors an amount calculated as if the borrowers had made only interest payments on the loans. Individuals A and B also funded the shortage in the Account X with money collected from new investors and by withholding payments from the Account X owed to Taxpayer. By the end of Year 5, Individuals A and B had used more than Amount 1 of Taxpayer's funds to make payments to other Company investors on non-performing loans.

Oh what a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive.  The tax problem you have when dealing with a mess like this  is like unscrambling an egg.  The taxpayers recognized income that wasn't really there. In principle you should amend open returns and to some extent might not have any relief. Rev Proc 2009-20 which was issued in light of the Bernie Madoff mess


allows taxpayers to take a theft loss in the year that the excrement strikes the air moving device in the amount of their unrecovered investment including fictitious income they reported.  It's a lot easier and possibly more favorable for something that went on a long time.  The treatment is an optional safe harbor.  At least according to this ruling you didn't have to have your money stolen by Bernie Madoff to qualify.

(1) Taxpayer is the qualified investor for purposes of claiming a theft loss deduction under Rev. Proc. 2009-20.



(2) The discovery year for purposes of claiming a theft loss deduction under Rev. Proc. 2009-20 is Year 8.


Songie S. Milhouse, et vir., v. Commissioner, TC Summary Opinion 2009-012
Stacey L. Cody, et vir. v. Commissioner, TC Summary Opinion 2011-49

The box on the return where you check "Married Filing Jointly" should have a big warning label maybe something like "Just because many gay people are mad that they aren't supposed to check this box, doesn't mean it's always such a good idea."  I must say I admire the principled civil disobedience approach of the Refuse to Lie campaign.  It happens that my own attitude toward taxes is generally "It is what it is.  Deal with it."  The dark side of Married Filing Jointly is known as "joint and several liability".  It means that the IRS can collect the entire tax deficiency from which ever of the pair they can lay their hands on.  There is a very easy defense against joint and several liability. It is called filing a separate return.  Then there is the much more challenging "innocent spouse" defense which often turns the Tax Court into a soap opera.

The Milhouse case was not particularly dramatic:

Throughout the marriage, petitioner mostly separated herself financially from Mr. Todd because of a "pattern" of "financial mismanagement" which she perceived on the part of Mr. Todd. Wages and child support payments which petitioner received were therefore deposited into her individual bank account. Mr. Todd, however, deposited his wages into a bank account jointly held with petitioner (joint account). Funds deposited into the joint account were used to pay household expenses and make improvements to Mr. Todd's house. While petitioner had access to the joint account, she never in fact accessed it. Instead, petitioner periodically transferred money to the joint account when Mr. Todd requested that she do so.

Petitioner sent to respondent a Form 8857, Request for Innocent Spouse Relief, which respondent received on August 27, 2008. In her request for relief, petitioner stated that she reported "all" of her income and that she was "under the impression" that Mr. Todd had provided her with all yearend tax statements he received for inclusion on the joint return. Before petitioner's entitlement to relief was determined, respondent provided Mr. Todd with the opportunity to oppose relief by filing with respondent a Form 12509, Statement of Disagreement.



Mr. Todd sent to respondent his statement of disagreement, which respondent received on February 26, 2009. In that statement Mr. Todd asserted that petitioner "knew" about the retirement income because she had access to the joint account both online and through statements that were mailed to their residence. Mr. Todd also stated that he gave petitioner all year-end tax statements to be reported on the joint return. Respondent subsequently forwarded petitioner's request for relief to respondent's Office of Appeals for further consideration.

The Tax Court resolved the "He said. She Said" in favor of Ms. Milhouse:

Petitioner testified credibly that she transferred money to the joint account but did not access the account or have any knowledge regarding the funds being deposited into that account. This testimony supports petitioner's claim that she did not have actual knowledge of the items giving rise to the deficiency at the time she signed the return. We generally reject Mr. Todd's contradictory testimony as self- serving and incredible. See Tokarski v. Commissioner, 87 T.C. 74, 77 (1986). Such is especially appropriate given that Mr. Todd did not offer any corroborating evidence to support his allegations of actual knowledge on the part of petitioner.

The Cody case has more drama to it:

Petitioner and intervenor's marriage was not stable. Petitioner moved out of the marital home with the children on more than one occasion. After each departure petitioner and the children returned to the marital home. At some point during the marriage intervenor was charged with misdemeanor domestic assault. Near the end of the marriage petitioner and intervenor began to experience financial difficulty. Petitioner became aware that the amount of intervenor's income was decreasing. They received foreclosure documents for the marital home dated October 26, 2007. On November 18, 2007, petitioner permanently separated from intervenor. Petitioner and intervenor eventually divorced on September 17, 2008.



As of the time of trial, petitioner, as the custodial parent, supported herself and the three children on her Social Security income. Petitioner received $916 a month for herself and $152 a month for each child. Petitioner's expenses exceeded her income by approximately $800 a month. When petitioner ran out of money each month, she visited a food bank to provide meals for her children.


Here is my advice to IRS collections.  You will probably do better chasing people who are eating at high end restaurants rather than lining up at the food pantries.  Just an opinion.  Don't want to tell you how to do your job.

Petitioner and intervenor initially did not file Federal income tax returns for the years 2002, 2003, 2004, and 2005. Respondent prepared substitutes for returns (SFRs)  for each of the tax years at issue for intervenor, and intervenor was sent a notice of deficiency. Intervenor did not respond to the notice, and taxes and additions to tax of $370, $5,242, $13,959, and $11,517 for 2002 through 2005, respectively, were assessed against intervenor.

Note that Mrs. Cody probably was not required to file a return.  I would have advised her to file one anyway, married filing separate, because in some situations taxpayers have been deemed to have consented to a joint return.  What Mrs. Cody ended up doing was, I must say, less than smart :


After the assessments, intervenor prepared joint Federal income tax returns for all of the years at issue. Intervenor contacted petitioner and asked that she execute those joint returns. Because she was afraid to meet intervenor alone, petitioner, accompanied by her adult niece, met with intervenor in a parking lot to sign the returns. Petitioner signed the returns without reviewing them on November 26, 2007. The returns reported tax liabilities due of $332, $2,713, $9,793, and $6,927 for 2002 through 2005, respectively.

Above we see the allure of the joint return.  By getting his estranged spouse to sign joint returns Mr. Cody reduced the liability for four years from slightly over 30,000 to slightly less than 20,000. What was Mrs. Cody getting out of this other than an opportunity to demonstrate to Mr. Cody what a formidable niece she had ? Further what did Mr. Cody get out of it ultimately other giving the IRS somebody else to chase ?  I suppose he got the satisfaction of seeing his ex-spouse have some more aggravation.

The Court then went into the various factors considered in innocent spouse cases


I. Marital Status



II. Economic Hardship



III. Knowledge or Reason To Know



IV. Nonrequesting Spouse's Legal Obligation



V. Significant Benefit


VI. Compliance With Federal Tax Laws

VII. Abuse and Mental or Physical Health



The only thing that was clearly against her was that the divorce decree had called for the parties to split the income tax liability.  The parking lot incident, in the analysis, kind of split.  All the surrounding circumstances of her signing the return indicate that she knew that the tax was not going to be paid.  On the other hand the fact that she brought her, presumably formidable, adult niece along helped support her abuse contention.

Of course if she had been my aunt, I would have prepared married filing separate returns for her driven her to the post office to mail them and then taken her for ice cream at a Friendly's on the opposite side of the city from where she was supposed to meet my ex-uncle. That would probably have been a better result.  It's exciting to have a niece in special ops, but sometimes a CPA nephew is what you really need.






































































Friday, June 3, 2011

Another Tax "Benefit" of Marriage

CCA 201112016

I have blogged a bit about same sex couple tax issues.  As a matter of fact, my all time most highly trafficed post is on the issue. Another of my posts was republished in Bay Windows, New England's largest GLBT paper. Although I admire the principled call to civil disobedience of the Refuse to Lie group, I have not really taken a stand on the issue.  There are two reasons for this.  One is that I have decided to be the Humphrey Bogart of tax bloggers - "It is what it is.  Deal with it."  More importantly, spending mental energy on what tax laws should be is a distraction from understanding what they are and how best to deal with them.  Frustration with the system not recognizing your marriage can distract you from the ways in which you might take advantage of the situation.  Basically, being married and filing a joint return is not an unmixed blessing.  I've pointed it out in numerous posts and now here is another great advantage of being married - having your withholdings applied to your spouses pre-mairtal tax debts:

Release Date: 3/25/2011 Office: ———————


UILC: 6402.02-00


From: —————————— Sent: Wednesday, February 16, 2011 10:34:59 AM To: —————————— Cc: —————————- Subject: Injured Spouse and Community Property Question


Hello —————- this is in response to your request for advice.


ISSUE:You have asked whether a wife who lives with her husband in California, a community property state, is eligible for injured spouse relief from the offset provisions of I.R.C. § 6402.


FACTS: The couple filed a joint return. The couple had wages withheld for taxes throughout the year, and would have gotten a refund but for the offset provision of section 6402, which allowed the Service to apply that refund towards a tax liability that the husband occurred prior to this marriage. The wife claims that she is entitled to a refund of part of this offset as an “injured spouse,” arguing that her wages are separate property because they are directly deposited into a separate bank account. She bases her claim that her wages are separate property on Cal. Fam. Code § 911, which provides:


Earnings of a married person during marriage are not liable for a debt incurred by the person's spouse before marriage. After the earnings of the married person are paid, they remain not liable so long as they are held in a deposit account in which the person's spouse has no right of withdrawal and are uncommingled with other property in the community estate, except property insignificant in amount.


CONCLUSION:The wife is not eligible for a refund because the amount of the refund comes from community property. The amount withheld never reached her bank account.

ANALYSIS: In California, wages earned by either of the spouses is community property. Cal. Fam. Code § 760; In re Marriage of Haines, 39 Cal. Rptr. 2d 673, 681 (1995); Martin v. Southern Pacific Co., 130 Cal. 285 (1900). Here, the amount that the wife is requesting to be refunded is the amount of her withheld wages that went towards satisfaction of her husband's pre-marriage tax liability. Those wage withholdings never went into any separately maintained bank account. Therefore, she is not entitled to a refund because wages are community property and the amounts withheld from those wages are of the same character. Further, the amounts withheld from those wages and subjected to refund offset to pay the tax liability were never available for deposit into a separate account maintained by her.

In addition, we note that Cal. Fam. Code § 911 is a state exemption statute, which does not bind the Service for collection purposes. In U.S. v. Mitchell, 403 U.S. 190 (1971), the United States Supreme Court addressed the issue of whether state exemption statutes affect the Service's authority to collect by levy. The Court held that they do not, stating, “exempt status under state law does not bind the federal collector. Federal law governs what is exempt from federal levy.” Mitchell at 205.

Please let me know if you have any further questions. Thank you!——————————————-—————————-—-

It is interesting to speculate on how this would have worked out if the couple had filed separate returns. There might then have been a refund check to the wife which she could have deposited in a separate account.  Whether the IRS would have somehow used the community property laws to grab it is something I'm not clear on.

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

What Is So Great About Sliced Bread ?

CCA 201106013

The controversy around the constitutionality of Section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act is much larger than the income tax issues it raises.  According to a  GAO report, as of December 31, 2003, there were 1,138 provisions in the United States Code in which marital status enters into determining eligibility for "benefits, rights and privileges".  By my count 22 of them fell under Title 26, better known as the Internal Revenue Code.  I would quibble with the list in that it includes Section 6015 - Relief from joint liability.  Joint liability is a pickle you can only get yourself in if your are considered to be married so I don't know that the ability to wiggle out of it should count towards the 1,138 - still its a quibble.  Oddly enough, I don't see Section 6013, which allows you to file a joint return on the list.  Of course the list does not include Section 267 which denies losses on transactions between related parties.  Being able to take a loss when you sell something to somebody is benefit of not being married to them.  One of my earliest posts was on the tax benefits that an unmarried couple has, particularly if they do some clever planning.

With all that said denying joint return status to same sex married couples seems to be the most talked about aspect of Section 3 of DOMA even provoking a principled civil disobedience campaign called Refuse to Lie.  A very large number of people need to file tax returns, many more than need concern themselves with the United States-Chile Free Trade Implementation Act (which is also on the GAO list), so I guess it makes sense.  So it always bothers me when I have to bring up the question - If being able to file a joint return is the greatest thing since sliced bread - what is so great about sliced bread ?  The worst thing about joint returns which I have pointed out frequently in posts like this one is joint and several liability, which is not all that easy to wiggle out of despite Section 6015.  Joint returns also produce messes like the one this CCA is addressing:



From: —————————————- Sent: Monday, January 10, 2011 2:23:03 PM To: ———————- Cc: ——————————————————————— ———————————————————- Subject: Allocation of Joint Credits- Elect and Estimated, ———————————


You have asked for advice regarding allocation of an overpayment from a married couple's joint return in year 1, which was credited to estimated tax in year 2. The taxpayers were divorcing when their ———- returns were due. They filed separately, but did have their returns completed by the same preparer. The TPW claimed 100% of the joint credit-elect from ———- and 100% of the estimated tax payments. The TPH's ———-separate liability was $————-; the TPW's ———- separate liability was $——————-. The TPH claimed NO pre-payment credits and in fact paid in the $——- due per his separate return.


The two credits, which were posted under the TPH's SSN because they'd filed joint the previous year, were transferred from the TPH's SSN to the TPW's.


The TPH subsequently filed an amended return (presumably timely) where he claimed 50% of the credit-elect from ———-. He did not similarly claim any part of the estimated tax payments. TPH appears to have acted unilaterally, as TPW did not file a complimentary amended return.


You raised three questions: Question 1 : Are the taxpayers' original ———- returns valid evidence of an agreement between the spouses as to the allocation of the credit-elect from ———- and the ————-estimated tax payments

Question 2: Are the credit-elect from ———- and the ———- estimated tax payments correctly attributable 100% to the TPW
Question 3: Was the allowance of the TPH's amended return (see below) erroneous and must it be reversed/disallowed
Issue 1: An overpayment in year 1 on a joint return ceases to be an overpayment and becomes an estimated tax payment once the couple elects to credit the amount to the next year's estimated taxes. See sections 6402(b) and 301.6402-3(a)(5). The allocation of estimated tax payments is not addressed in the Code, however, Reg. 1.6654-2(e)(5)(ii) explains how joint payments of estimated taxes should be allocated to separate returns. Regulation 1.6654-2(e)(5)(ii) provides for allocation of estimated tax payments to either husband, wife, or divided between each's tax liability by agreement of the parties.


Rev. Rul. 76-140, 1976-1 C.B. 376, addresses a similar factual situation, under prior Code section 6015(b). The treatment under the previous Code section is identical to the current treatment. The section has simply been renumbered with the conversion of section 6015 to addressing innocent spouse claims. Therefore, the reasoning of the Revenue Ruling remains sound.

In Rev. Rul. 76-140, we indicated the policy that where taxpayers filed consistent returns in year 2 allocating estimated tax payments, those returns would be considered evidence of an agreement between the parties as to allocation of the estimated tax payments. A subsequent refund claim, without further evidence of a different agreement between the parties, should be disallowed. As such, the taxpayers' original -———- returns are valid evidence of an agreement between the spouses as to the allocation of the ———- estimated tax payments, which include the credit-elect from ———-———-.


Issue 2: Because the original returns for ———- evidence an agreement between the parties to allocate 100% of the estimated tax payments to TPW, such an allocation is acceptable under Treas. Reg. 1.6654-2(e)(5)(ii).


Issue 3: If the Service issued a refund to TPH for the estimated tax payments requested on his 1040X, then an erroneous refund has been made. If TPH's account was credited but no refund was made, the credit may be reversible.


If you have any further questions or comments, please do not hesitate to contact me at the address above or —————————-. Thank you-————————————————————— —————— ———————

Like divorce doesn't produce enough aggravation, you need one more thing.

OK.  I actually do know that it can be quite advantageous to file jointly in many situations and not just because of the bracket creep.  That's why I was writing posts like this one about not missing the deadline for amending 2007 returns.  And believe it or not I found out what is so great about sliced bread.  A friend of mine who spent time in a back to the land type of lifestyle told me its real hard to make sandwiches when you bake your own bread.

Monday, April 25, 2011

What is Nothing ?

                            What did you get, kid ?
                             I didn't get nothing. 
                            I had to pay $50 and pick up the garbage

Estate Of Axel O. Adler v. Commissioner, TC Memo 2011-28

I thought I'd be able to make more out of this, but there is really a very simple point.  If you want valuation discounts, don't rely on fractional interest in real estate.  Form a family limited partnership.

Private Letter Ruling 201104066

I find that the hardest things to go through are private letter rulings.  They come in fairly tedious batches of late S elections and IRA rollover mishaps.  It's rare that there is anything really interesting except denials of exempt status.  Nothing yet has risen to the level of comic masterpiece equivalent to the tax court decision in Free Fertility, but some of them are pretty good.  This one was about horses.  I think the IRS has something against horses:

The general purpose of this corporation shall be to identify, conserve, safeguard, and propagate the genetic integrity of the horse originally found in the possession of the Tr. in Country, and those bred in other countries by breeders whose foundation stock was drawn entirely from those tribes of the T



Your Articles further provide, "the purpose shall be accomplished through research of historical and genetic (scientific) data to add to the X or disqualify horses from the 'X', according to the standards as set down in said 'X'. The purpose shall be additionally accomplished through education of the international horse community, the general public, and youth (by publication), regarding historic, genetic and athletic value of these endangered genetic lines, and collection and sharing of historic artifacts, letters and documents."

I don't know.  Sounds pretty good to me.  IRS didn't like it:

You have not demonstrated that you do not inure to the benefit of private individuals. You, M, maintain a website, g, that contains links to private sellers of Q horses. Those breeders earn a profit, and private benefit, by being able to sell horses and/or stud services to interested persons. As a result, under section 1.501(c)(3)-d(1)(ii) of the regulations, you do not meet the requirements of section 501(c)(3) of the Code.

The Service did suggest that they might qualify under 501(c)(5):

You are similar to the organization described in Rev. Rul. 55-230. You are organized to guard the purity of the breed of Q horses; to promote interest therein; and to help fund research on the genetics of this breed of horses. You state that you are unlike this organization because you are not a horse registry. We disagree because you do maintain a partial horse registry, as you maintain listings of horses and their genetic parents in your newsletters. You are also similar to the organization described in Rev. Rul. 55-230 because you promote and fund research on the genetics of this particular breed of horse.


Michael P. Schwab, et ux. v. Commissioner, 136 T.C. No. 6

This is probably worth a full length post, but I'm not going to get to it.  In case you've been holding your breath, it's what ties in to the quotation from Alice's Restaurant.  The Schwabs had participated in something called an 'Advantage 419' plan, which then invested in variable life insurance policies.  When I was interviewed by The Wandering Tax Pro one of his questions was what is the best tax advice I could give to anyone.  Frankly, I lied.  I save my best advice for paying clients, but the best advice, which I can give for free is pretty good- Sometimes you should just pay the taxes. It's pretty clear that paying the taxes and stuffing the after tax income in a mattress would have been a better deal than this plan worked out to be.

 Because of IRS activity in the area, the Schwabs decided that their 419 plan wasn't such an advantage anymore.  The variable life insurance policies were distributed.  The taxpayers and the IRS were arguing about whether surrender charges should be considered in valuing the policies.  There was no net surrender value after considering surrender charges, so the taxpayers argued that like Arlo they didn't get nothing. The Court after grousing about the poor record it had to work with took a different approach.  It attempted to compute the fair market value of the policies, which as it turned out was something but not much.  Because of a no lapse provision the policies provided coverage for a short time before they expired.  The Court used standard valuation tables to come up with a value of about $2,000, which was more than 0, but a lot less than the $80,000 or so the IRS was arguing for.

Songie S. Milhouse, et vir., v. Commissioner, TC Summary Opinion 2009-012



This decision was dated 2/9/2011 so I suspect the number is wrong. That's what they have in RIA anyway and who am I to argue?  It is an innocent spouse case in which the spouse is found innocent.  Mrs. Milhouse had separated her finances from her husband because of a pattern of irresponsibility on his part.  She put money into a joint account that she had access to, but he ran.  The IRS thought that since she could have looked at the account, she should have known about his unreported income. 

Respondent did not offer any corroborating evidence at trial to support a finding that petitioner had actual knowledge of the items giving rise to the deficiency, nor did respondent substantively cross-examine petitioner or Mr. Todd on the scope of petitioner's knowledge. Petitioner, on the other hand, credibly disavowed any actual knowledge of the items giving rise to the deficiency and provided a vigorous cross-examination after Mr. Todd's direct testimony. Accordingly, we hold that petitioner did not have actual knowledge of the items giving rise to the deficiency that would preclude the granting of relief under section 6015(c)

It was good that Mrs. Milhouse won the case, but I think the lesson here is that if you think your spouse is not financially responsible, think very carefully before filing a joint return.  Just because the vast right wing conspiracy thinks civilization will end if gay people are allowed to file them doesn't mean they are always a good deal.





Friday, April 1, 2011

Deadline Looms for Same Sex Couples 2007 Amended Returns


There have been major developments in the tax law affecting same sex couples in the last year.  The attitude that I have as a tax advisor is "It is what it is.  Deal with it."  Whether its fair or makes sense is an interesting question, but not a practical one.  When I look at the developments my thought is "What should Robin and Terry do ?"  Robin and Terry are a couple of indeterminate gender and relationship status whose role in life is to help me avoid awkward pronoun problems.  It's been a big year for Robin and Terry.  I've decided that for this post I need to introduce some of their friends.  One couple is Alex and Marty.  The other is Blynn and Ashley.  They are going to be busy this week because despite my advice they put off looking at their 2007 returns to see if they should amend. 

Robin and Terry, at least for now, are of the same gender and were married in Massachusetts in 2007.  Alex and Marty are of the same gender and are California registered domestic partners.  Blynn and Ashley, who know how to act quickly when opportunity arises, are a California same sex married couple.  They were married in San Francisco in 2004.  Same sex marriage in California has a fairly convoluted legal history.  It's arguable that in 2007, there were no same sex married couples in California, but thanks to litigation decided in 2008, now there were. 

The development that affects Robin and Terry is the decision in Gill v OPM, which declared that Section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) is unconstitutional.  DOMA provides that for all purposes of federal law same sex marriages are not recognized.  The Obama administration has announced that it will no longer defend DOMA in court, although it will still be enforced pending appeals.  In order to benefit from the ultimate ruling, however, a claim must be filed while the statute of limitations is still open.

For 2007, Robin and Terry filed their returns as single.  It may be that they would have paid less tax if they had been able to do a married filing joint return.   I discussed the question of whether a joint return is better in a recent post, which was republished in Bay Windows.  The short answer is that there are enough potential complications that you really need to do the return in order to tell.  Now, Robin and Terry were required to file a joint Massachusetts return so it may be that somebody already prepared a pro-forma federal joint return for them.  That's how we would have done it anyway.  So one way or another Robin and Terry should compute a joint return and see if it would save them money.  It's not a sure bet that Gill v OPM will ultimately be upheld, but there is quite a good chance.  Unless there is a timely claim for refund, though, it won't do them any good for their 2007 return.

Alex and Marty have a situation that is more complicated, but not as uncertain.  CCA 201021050 holds that the IRS will recognize California community property law as it relates to registered domestic partners.  So Alex and Marty will still file as single (or head of household), but each will report half of the "community income", which includes wages.  This holding is mandatory for 2010 returns and is causing a lot of heartburn.  IRS has reissued a Publication 555 to help explain it. One of the subtleties in this is that not all income is community income and it is only community income that is split. The CCA made filing amended returns for open years optional.

There are a host of phase-outs and thresholds and offsets such that it is really impossible to say with certainty what will happen when you start moving income from one return to another.  You have to look at each return.  Let's say however that Alex and Marty don't have much other than their jobs and that Alex gets paid a ton of money by Microsoft as an independent contractor and  Marty works at Starbucks.  Most likely if they prepare amended returns for 2007 Alex will get a big refund and Marty will owe a lot of money.  They will, however, net positive, at least on tax, if not on interest.

I did come up with a nasty idea.  I've only found one other commentator that has made a similar observation:

Observation: The CCA doesn't say that if one partner amends his or her return, the other must do so as well. So, feasibly the higher income partner could amend his or her return to claim only 50% of his or her earnings while the lower income partner does nothing (i.e., doesn't file an amended return to pick up his or her 50% share). However, as withholding must also be split 50/50, it may be necessary to file both returns to get the full benefit of any savings. Also, the IRS may well require both partners to amend under these circumstances.

That comes from William Bischoff from a National Tax Advisory (NTA-743) (I can't track down a free link to it.  I got it from my RIA Checkpoint subscription).  I have not found anything to indicate that the IRS has done something to prevent being whipsawed on this issue.  So if Alex hurries out and amends for 2007, maybe kind of forgetting to mention it to Marty, it may well be that Marty will be protected by the statute of limitations.  I doubt that there is a SWAT team sitting in the service centers ready to issue timely notices of deficiency to the registered domestic partners of people filing refund claims under CCA 201021050, but I never, ever, give advice even to hypothetical clients based on the audit lottery.  This particular observation is why I titled my first post on this topic Windfall for "Unmarried" Taxpayers.  Other commentators that I have noted are good doobies on this issue.  I guess I would say that if Alex amends, maybe Marty should too, but that maybe Marty doesn't have to be in such a rush about it. Also I should note that if Marty had income low enough to not have filed a 2007 return (or didn't file one anyway), there is no statute of limitations protecting Marty.

I won't spend much time on Blynn and Ashley.  They do not represent a very large group of people.  San Francisco issued same sex couples marriage licences for a brief period in 2004.  That was shut down, but the law that declared it illegal was declared unconstitutional in 2008 opening a state wide window, which was closed in November 2008 by Proposition 8.  So of the approximately 18,000 legally married same sex couples in California only a small number would have been arguably married in 2007 (at least in retrospect).  What is interesting about them is they can either filed an amended joint 2007 return like Robin and Terry or amended 2007 community returns like Alex and Marty.  The Alex and Marty option will probably work out better, but I find their situation particularly interesting so I thought I would mention it.

There is another point, which I cannot emphasize enough.  If you might benefit from amending your 2007 return and you did not put it on extension,get the amended return done NOW.  In CCA 201052003, it was noted that the "timely mailed, timely filed" rule only applies to returns that are "required to be filed".  So an amended return to be timely must be received by the IRS before the statute expires.  I'm not going to get into whether that is April 15th or April 18th.  Don't take chances.  Get it done this week and send it return receipt.

P.S.

Patricia Cain of the Santa Clara Same Sex Tax Blog has set me straight on one issue.  The 18,000 figure that I picked up from that unimpeachable source, Wikipedia is the number of California same sex marriages in 2008.  She indicates that there were over 4,000 licenses issued to same sex couples in San Francisco in 2004, but none of those marriages were valid.  So it may well be that not only do Blynn and Ashley not exist, there may actually not be anybody like them.  The principle would apply for 2008 amended returns, but there is no rush to get those done and it is probably better to wait for more guidance.

Ms. Cain does not like the idea of the high income partners amending and the other partner letting it slide. It's not my all time favorite idea either, I just haven't figured out why it doesn't work.  You really need to go to the Santa Clara blog for a thorough treatment of same sex tax issues.  They are very focused on the issue and don't get distracted  by mercenaries and celebrity underwear.

Another point that I also picked up from Ms. Cain that I should have thought of myself is that the lower earning partner might be subject to a six year statute of limitations if his or her share of community income would be 25% greater than the income he or she reported..

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Some More Randomness

Here are a few developments that don't seem to merit a full treatement and are starting to get a little stale.

Richard H. Franke v. Commissioner, TC Memo 2011-10

I really thought I could make something of this.  It was about whether somebody who had fallen for a tax protester type package was liable for fraud penalties.  He was only arguing about money.  The people who created the package are doing time. The scheme was based on creating a "Corporation Sole", which is a legal form used generally by religious groups to associate title to property with whoever holds a particular office.

What was really interesting was that Mr. Franke was an enrolled agent and he was using the scheme to shelter his tax preparation income.  He was continuing to insist to the Tax Court that he believed the scheme worked as they found him liable for the penalty.  I generally think that enrolled agents don't get enough respect so I was kind of disappointed.

TRC, INC. v. U.S., Cite as 107 AFTR 2d 2011-XXXX

The company was trying for a refund of penalties for failure to timely pay over payroll withholdings.  They were not successful.  The decision emphasized that withholings are special in that the money was never yours in the first place :

In determining if the taxpayer exercised ordinary business care and prudence in providing for the payment of his tax liability, consideration will be given to the nature of the tax which the taxpayer has failed to pay. Thus, for example, facts and circumstances which, because of the taxpayer's efforts to conserve assets in marketable form, may constitute reasonable cause for nonpayment of income taxes may not constitute reasonable cause for failure to pay over taxes described in section 7501 that are collected or withheld from any other person.


Although it is the duty of the court to weigh all of the factors identified in the regulations, “it will be the rare case where the government is made “the unwilling partner in a floundering business” without the employer incurring the duty to pay a penalty for having made such a choice” to fail to pay trust fund taxes over to the government on a timely basis.

The best thing for small businesses is to use a service like Paychex.  If you don't have the money to pay over the withholdings, it really means that you don't have the money to make payroll.

Private Letter Ruling 201101028, 01/07/2011

This was a withdrawal of exempt status,  The organization was supposed to be raising funds for charities.  It's only activity was gambling, apparently Bingo, and contributions from other organizations controlled by the same person.  It may be that they applied for exempt status in the first place in order to be able to get licensed for the gambling.  It seems like many organizations apply for exempt status more to get some sort of state law privilege or creditability with actual exempt organizations or local and state governments.  The IRS probably has enough to do collecting federal revenue without being used as vehicle for liquor licenses and gambling permits.  But as I often say "It is what it is.  Deal with it."

Private Letter Ruling 201101027, 01/07/2011

This one is another revocation of exempt status, this time for "inurement".  It was pretty convoluted.  I'll just give you a taste of what ORG (The not really not for profit) was up to:

Given the facts, it appears that CO-2, DIR-6 as president, purchased the land in January 19XX from LAND order to build a golf course; which was also on or around the time the land was discovered to contain toxins, which would have certainly devalued the land at that point in time Not able to build a golf course due the toxins, CO-2 then only held the land for an 8-month period who would then sell the land to CO-1 who would also only hold it for an 8-month period before selling it to ORG at a value that may or may not have been the fair market value given the discovery of the toxins in the land. Without contemporaneous certified appraisals the value of the land during each sale remains unknown. To state that no appraisals were ever conducted for any of these transactions is unlikely since most land and property sales are accompanied by a certified appraisal.


ORG has not demonstrated that the transaction with DIR-6 was in fact at arms-length. Without a certified appraisal at the time the land was sold to ORG and in light of value of land recorded by the county, the facts indicate that ORG purchased land that was grossly overvalued. This transaction allowed the FAMILY to divest ORG of several hundred thousand dollars as illustrated below:

Few things trouble me more than people using exempt organizations to enrich themselves.

Valarie N. Stephenson v. Commissioner, TC Memo 2011-16

This was an innocent spouse case.  It is one where the taxpayer won for a change.  That she had to go to Tax Court is indicative of how hard it is for people to win these cases.  There are 8 factors that are considered, one of which is abuse by non-requesting spouse.  Here is what she had on that one:

Mr. Stephenson abused petitioner throughout their marriage. During trial petitioner provided specific examples of abuse, including a time when Mr. Stephenson threatened to kill her or himself if she left him and times when Mr. Stephenson threw items at her. Mr. Stephenson regularly humiliated petitioner in front of his family and their friends and demeaned her when she asked questions. Mr. Thomas corroborated some of petitioner's testimony by credibly testifying that petitioner had bruises on her body and told him that she was in an abusive relationship.


I know it is more a matter of principle, but the denial of joint filing to same sex couples is probably not quite the hardship they think it is.  Joint and several liability is the dark side of joint return filing that most planners, even divorce attorneys, who should know better, ignore.

Unless something really huge happens, there will be quite a few posts like this in the next couple of weeks as I have a pretty big backlog and not much time to give things the full treatment.

Monday, March 14, 2011

Congress Provides Subsidy to Gay Marriage

The official position of this blog on all matter of what the tax law should be is "It is was it is. Deal with it."  I observe and seek practical pointers, humor and matter for reflection.  I break my rule of indifference to what "should be" from time to time. The tax ramifications of the Defense of Marriage Act provide enough interesting items, that there is no need for my opinion.

Just to bring you up to speed, Section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act provides, that, for all purposes of federal law, marriage is only between persons of opposite gender and the word spouse means someone of the opposite gender.  Several states, including Massachusetts, allow persons of the same gender to marry.  Such persons are considered either single or head of household (depending on their circumstances) for federal income tax purposes.  Accordingly they are not eligible to file joint returns.  I have a mythical couple called Robin and Terry, whom I invented to avoid awkward pronoun problems.  Robin and Terry are of indeterminate gender and marital status.  For purposes of this post, they are of the same gender and were married in Massachusetts in 2007.

Section 3 of DOMA has been the subject of litigation.  The Federal District Court of Massachusetts in Gill v OPM has ruled that it is unconstitutional, because it has no rational basis.  The Justice Department had indicated that it would appeal the ruling.  Generally the Justice Department defends the constitutionality of laws passed by Congress regardless of what the current administration thinks of them.  The view is that "unconstitutional" and "bad idea" are not synonymous.  The Justice Department has recently, however, concluded that Section 3 of DOMA is indefensible.  So the Administration will not fight it in court any more.  They will continue to enforce it.  So as far as the IRS is concerned Robin and Terry are still not married.

If I were in charge of the vast right wing conspiracy what I would do is have Congress now repeal Section 3 of DOMA.  What they would say is that they were repealing it not on an equal protection theory, but because it violates the 10th Amendments.  It's up to the states to decided who is or is not married and if a couple of states are infected by crazy liberal ideas, the rest of just have to live with it.  Besides, there is some evidence that on net the overall collection of federal tax would be higher if same sex marriages were recognized for federal purposes.

Instead conservative congressman are going to have Congress take up the defense of DOMA in the courts.  By doing this they are, in effect, subsidizing same sex marriages.  Here is why.  People whose marriages are recognized for federal taxes can file either jointly or married filing separately.  People whose marriages are not recognized for federal purposes file as single or head of household depending on their circumstances.  Of the four rate tables married filing separate is the worst.  I just ran the numbers on someone who was single as if he were married filing separately.  It cost him about $4,000.  Taking two married filing separate returns and turning them into joint will almost always save money (An exception might be if one of them had large medical expenses).  Taking two single returns or a single return and a head of household return and turning them into a joint return is much more unpredictable.  It could go either way. ( I should also point out that there is a benefit to the government from joint returns that taxpayers and planners often ignore. By filing a joint return the taxpayers assume joint and several liability. That means the government can collect the whole tax from either one of them.) So the ideal situation would be for you to be able to choose on a year to year basis whether you are single or married for federal income tax purposes.  The unwillingness of Congress to throw in the towel on Section 3 of DOMA, in effect, puts Robin and Terry in that situation.

Under the law in effect now Robin and Terry are single for federal income tax purposes.  If that gives them the most favorable tax, they can just file that way and not worry.  I don't think there is any likelihood that if Section 3 of DOMA is declared unconstitutional there will be examinations of returns of people who have been filing as single.  If I was in charge of the vast right wing conspiracy, I would certainly be threatening that.  "You want marriage equality.  Fine you have it.  Send in four grand."  When the IRS recently ruled that registered domestic partners in community property states have to split their income, they made filing amended returns for open years optional.  Presumably if Gill v OPM is upheld, there will be a similar outcome.

Because of Gill v OPM, however, Robin and Terry have a reasonable basis for filing a joint return if that saves them money.  The conservative thing to do is to file as single and then put in a claim for refund, but if they are feeling wild and crazy they can just file the money saving joint return and their only exposure should be the interest.  Now I am precluded from giving advice based on the audit lottery, but an observation I would make as a policy matter, is that there is nowhere on the return, where they ask you what your gender is.  It is conceivable that I could prepare Robin and Terry's return and engage to represent them in an audit without knowing what the gender of either of them was.  If they told me they were of the same gender, I'd tell them all about DOMA and Gill v OPM, etc, but frankly if Robin came in with all the information or we handled everything through the mail or our portal, it would not occur to me to ask.  It's a little antediluvian, but you have to be careful about asking guys my age whether they are married to a guy.

So, there is a very respectable conservative argument for repealing Section 3 of DOMA (States rights) and continuing the court fight means that same sex married couples, in the aggregate will be paying less federal tax.  Is this the working of the vast left wing conspiracy ? Is the vast right wing conspiracy shooting itself in the foot ? Or is much of the world run by random knee jerk reactions without much long term thought ?  To me when it comes to tax law my motto is "It is what it is. Deal with it." How it gets that way is a little mysterious and of little practical importance.

I think I'm going to give Robin and Terry a break for a while.  There are some other developments that I will focus on in the next few posts.

Sunday, February 27, 2011

Amended Returns Due to DOMA Case - What Needs to be Done

This blog is my blog so I make the rules and get to decide when I'm going to break them.  One of the rules is that I don't talk about what the tax laws should or should not be.  The motto is "It is what it is. Deal with it."  So I observe, find humor, matter for reflection or practical implications.  When an ordained trumpet player gets a $195,000 "parsonage exclusion" on his second home, I might break the rule and express an opinion.  DOMA has enough people expressing opinions, so I'm sticking with the practical implications.  If you would like some passionately informed opinion check out Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders and the Massachusetts Family Institute.  GLAD was managing the plaintiff side of Gill v OPM.  MFI says it will be seeking to pick up the defense ball that the Administration has abandoned.  Both organizations agree that the case is important.  Other than that they appear to differ.

What I'm thinking about is what Robin and Terry should do. Robin and Terry are a couple of indeterminate gender and marital status who were invented to help me deal with awkward pronoun problems.  For now they are of the same gender, live in Massachusetts and were legally married in Massachusetts in 2007.  If I was writing a novel, this is the church, where they were married, but that level of detail is really not necessary.  The administration's decision doesn't really change my opinion on what needs to be done.  It just increases the urgency a bit, since it makes it somewhat more likely that part of DOMA will be definitively declared unconstitutional.

Robin and Terry have been filing their federal returns as single, because they are law abiding.  I'm going to assume that they have foregone all the clever ideas I described in my post on the tax advantages of not being married for federal income tax purposes.  So there is a chance that if they were allowed to file a joint federal return their aggregate tax liability would be lower.  So can they just wait for the DOMA drama to resolve itself and then file amended returns?  Not exactly.  Any refund claim they make has to be filed before the statute of limitations expires for that year.  Putting aside extensions that means that 2007 is looming.  I'm not going to get into a fine tuned discussion of Emancipation Day and Patriots Day.  The statute expires in the middle of April and the IRS has to receive the claim before the statute expires (No timely mailed, timely filed rule for amended returns). So get this taken care of soon.

How can you tell if Robin and Terry will save money by filing a joint return ?  There is really only one way.  You have to do the return.  Someone might tell you that the wider their discrepancy in income, the more likely they are to benefit from a joint filing and conversely if their incomes are close DOMA is probably saving them income tax.  Computing federal income tax, however, involves a host of thresholds, percentage computation and special limitations.  To take a simple example.  Robin and Terry each make $200,000 per year in salary.  Robin is a brilliant stock picker.  Terry is, well, an idiot when it comes to investing.  Robin has $300,000 in capital gains.  Terry has a $500,000 capital loss carryover that promises to last out the new millennium if Terry should live so long.  On the separate returns there is a positive $300,000 on one return and a negative $3,000 on the other.  On a joint return there is just the negative $3,000.

Another example.  Robin makes $250,000 and Terry makes $75,000.  Terry has $40,000 in medical expenses while Robin has none.  Terry's medical deduction is $34,375.  That would be reduced to $15,625 on a joint return because of the higher 7.5% threshold.

One more example.  Robin makes $75,000 per year and Terry makes $300,000.  Robin owns some rental properties that amazingly lose money.  Robin actively participates in running the properties and deducts $25,000 of the losses, the other $10,000 being suspended.  On a joint return with Terry they would all be suspended unless, of course, Terry owned a real estate brokerage business.  Then they could all be currently deducted.

Then there is the alternative minimum tax.  Don't even get me started.

This particular problem does not require the conceptual thinking of a tax attorney or an algorithm designed by a software engineer.  It requires a seasoned tax preparer, preferably one with good software.

I don't think it is at all likely that DOMA being declared unconstitutional will affect the returns of people who filed as single, whose tax would be higher if they had been considered married.  CCA 201021050 ruled that registered domestic partners in community property states should each report half of their own and their partners income.  The ruling made amending returns for open years optional.  Presumably it would be the same for a DOMA change.  The optional money saving amended returns will only be available for open years, though.  Only those who file claims before the statute expires on each year will be able to benefit from those years.

The other consideration in filing joint returns, which I mentioned in last week's post on this issue is joint and several liability.  If Robin thinks that Terry may have omitted significant income, then Robin should not join in an amended return regardless of the apparent savings. 

So that's it for the practical aspect, which I must say seems to be largely neglected in the rest of the blogosphere.  I do have two reflections on the issue.  The first is that I think it is fascinating that someone with a very conservative view of the Constitution should really likely the Gill decision.  It is a states rights case.  It has always been up to the states to say who is or is not married and DOMA is a violation of that principle.  I'm still searching for the honest person that doesn't have the same opinion on Gill v OPM and Perry vs. Schwarzenegger, because of their strong belief in either states rights or federal supremacy.  I think that the Constitution is generally used by activists as a drunk uses a lamppost, more for support than illumination. 

The other observation, which may seem slightly mawkish, though I assure it is quite sincere, is that I feel very blessed that I live in a country where GLAD and MFI are fighting this battle with briefs and news releases.  As I noted they both seem to agree that what the court has to say is very important.  I don't think we are always as grateful for that type of agreement, as we should be.

Post Script

The Santa Clara Law Same Sex Tax Law Blog has posted something on the practical points of filing for a refund based on the DOMA decisions.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

DOMA Unconstitutional - Practical Tips

In a quick bonus post yesterday I noted that the Obama administration has decided to no longer defend the Defense of Marriage Act against constitutional challenges.  As it turns out that was a bit of an overstatement. I usually don't write on things that "everybody else" is writing about, but the tax issues surrounding same sex couples have been one of my themes.  Also I offer a somewhat different perspective.  My general attitude toward tax law is "It is what it is.  Deal with it."

So here are some practical observations.  If you are intensely interested in the nuts and bolts of same sex tax issues, I recommend you follow Santa Clara Law - Same Sex Tax.  That blog may be a little West Coast focused, but I recommend it regardless.  In Massachusetts the exciting decision in 2010, was Gill v OPM.  The case which had several plaintiffs was managed by Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders.  Although GLAD's statement on the administration's decision is positive, it is less than celebratory, because the decision isn't quite as sweeping as some media reports make it out to be. There are two caveats.  The first is that the administration only said it will not defend DOMA in the Second Circuit where it would be subject to "strict scrutiny".  It is still possible that they may continue to defend in the First Circuit which covers Gill v OPM where the standard is "rational basis".  The holding in Gill was that the law did not have a "rational basis" (In other words, it doesn't even make good nonsense).  That question may be still up for grabs.  The other caveat is that the executive branch will continue to enforce DOMA until it is either repealed or declared definitively unconstitutional.  That means, I would think, that there will be no helpful guidance from the IRS.

The Mass Family Institute, which did not take a positive view of the administration's decision, did not focus on those nuances in its statement.  It did point out that either house of Congress could appoint counsel to defend DOMA and that the Institute, itself, will seek standing to defend it in Gill v OPM.  As noted by GLAD, though, the administration has not thrown in the towel on Gill, at least not yet.

The best overall coverage I have seen on the story has been from the Keen New Service.

So what should Robin and Terry do ?  (Robin and Terry are a couple of indeterminate gender and marital status who were invented to help me deal with awkward pronoun problems)  In today's manifestation they are of the same gender and married in Massachusetts in 2007.  In 2007, they each filed returns as single.  Robin is on Terry's health insurance and Terry's employer included the related costs as part of Terry's wages.  If Robin and Terry were my clients, I'd be looking at their 2007 returns right now and what they could do is wait for my call. I would rough out two pro-forma amended returns.  One would be a joint return of Robin and Terry.  The other would be Terry, married filing separately, with income reduced by the denied medical insurance exclusion.  The chance that the latter would produce a meaningful refund strikes me as improbable,  but it would be pretty easy to do.   I would tell them that they should extend their 2010 returns.  This won't be sorted out by September (Yes I know the extended due date is in October, but I don't like being a "Last Minute Louie", as my mother used to say), but we might know more by then.

If an amended 2007 return would produce a significant refund, they should consider filing it.  Let me emphasize - Consider filing it.  Despite the bad advice of a legion of divorce attorneys, the decision to file a joint return is not a simple numbers exercise.  Filing jointly, as I have pointed out, involves the acceptance of joint and several liability.  If Robin thinks that Terry may have omitted to report substantial income then Robin should not join in an amended return.

Assuming that an amended return is a good idea, the other practical tip is to not delay too long.  Here is why.  For returns that are required to be filed there is a "timely mailed, timely filed" rule.  The Service noted however in CCA 201052003 that an amended return is not a return that is "required" so the 2007 amended return needs to be received by the IRS before the statute expires for 2007.  Please don't get into an argument about how Emancipation Day and Patriots Day might play into that determination.  Get it to them sometime in March.

For later years, the thing to do is to wait and see.

POSTSCRIPT

The government followed up with a withdrawal in Gill v OPM, but the release on it from GLAD indicates some ambiguity in the statement.  This in no way affects my advice on getting amended returns in to preserve rights.

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Time For Robin and Terry To Amend

This is a bonus post.  In October, I wrote a post on whether Massachusetts same sex couples who are married should consider filing amended returns.  It was follow-up to a slightly longer treatment I had done on Gill v OPM which had held that portions of the Defense of Marriage Act were unconstitutional.  DOMA has two major effects.  The first is that states that do not allow same sex marriage for their own residents do not have to recognize the validity of marriages performed in other states.  The second is that for all purposes of federal law marriage is defined as being between one man and one woman.  Gill was about the second piece of DOMA.  It was an action by several people who had been denied a variety of federal benefits by DOMA including the right to file an amended return.The effect of Gill was suspended pending appeal.

  Robin and Terry are a mythical couple of indeterminate gender and marital status who were invented to help me deal with awkward pronoun problems.

The news is that President Obama has ordered the Justice Department to stop defending DOMA.  Here is a link to the New York Times story.

In his letter, Mr. Holder said the administration legal team had decided that gay people merited the protection of the “heightened scrutiny” test, and that under that standard, the Defense of Marriage Act was impossible to keep defending as constitutional

See my more extensive follow-up on this.

Monday, January 3, 2011

Do You Have a Need To Know ?

CCA 201050029

I'm doing this one as a bonus post.  I have written several times on the perils of filing joint returns.  I have long been of the opinion that divorcing spouse in particular should reflect on the perils of joint and several liability rather than just looking at the relative tax amounts.  Several months ago I made a logical extension of that advice.  In my post on the Laura Brady case, I recommended that a spouse who has decided not to sign a joint return should file a separate return, even if not otherwise required to file.  This is because a non-signing spouse can be deemed to have consented to a joint return.

CCA 201050029 illustrates the dilemmas that can be created by not paying attention.  The Chief Counsel has to ponder whether someone should be informed about the contents of a joint return that he or she has denied signing.  Seem like it would be nice to know how much your ex is trying to hang you with.  I've read the thing a couple of times and am still not sure what the answer is.  Better to avoid the situation entirely.
From: ————————— Sent: Friday, November 05, 2010 9:50:31 AM To: ——————— Cc:


Subject: Your Inquiry


As a starting point, sections 6103(e)(1)(B) and 6103(e)(7) authorize the disclosure of a joint return, and return information relating thereto, to either of the “individuals with respect to whom the return is filed.” Your question concerns whether that authority remains viable when one such individual claims not to have signed the purported joint return. I believe it does; because there has been no final determination as to the spouse's tax liability stemming from the purported joint return, the spouse remains an “individual with respect to whom the return is filed.”


But there may be other authority as well. You can look to section 6103(h)(4). (Note that there is some overlap between the authorities in sections 6103(e) and (h) with respect to a taxpayer's ability to access his or her own information.) Section 6103(h)(4) establishes disclosure authority in “administrative and judicial proceedings pertaining to tax administration,” which include examinations and Appeals consideration. Subsections (A), (B), and (C) set forth the relevant authority for disclosure of return and return information to a taxpayer, either where that taxpayer is a “party to the proceeding” or the “proceeding arose out of, or in connection with, determining the taxpayer's liability” [subpart A], or where either of the third party tests [subparts B and C] apply. As noted above, because there has been no final determination as to the spouse's tax liability stemming from the purported joint return, it strikes me that the spouse remains a party to the matter that is before Appeals. Alternatively, depending on the particular facts, one or more of these other subparts may apply ———————————————————————————————————————————————————————————- ———————————————————————————————————————————————————————————- ———————————————————————————————————————————————————————————- ————————————————————————————————

Friday, December 24, 2010

What's New With The Chief Counsel ?

There have been quite a few items of interest from the chief counsel's office.  Here is what I think was worth noticing through mid December.  I've got next week ready to go and these will start getting stale, so I'll make this a Merry Christmas bonus post.

CCA 201049041

The IRS will not transfer or redesignate a payment that has been applied to a taxpayer's account to satisfy a different liability of the taxpayer if the payment was applied according to the taxpayer's instructions. If the IRS applies a payment contrary to a taxpayer's instructions, the IRS will, upon request by the taxpayer, transfer the payment to the intended tax liability.
A corporation that believes it will have overpaid its estimated tax for the tax year may apply for a quick refund on Form 4466, Corporation Application for Quick Refund of Overpayment of Estimated Tax, before the 16th day of the 3rd month after the end of the tax year at issue, but before it files its income tax return, if the overpayment is at least 10% of the expected tax liability and at least $500. A corporation should not file Form 4466 before the end of its tax year.
If you run into cash flow problems it would be nice if you could apply estimated income tax payments to payroll tax deposits, which have much more ferocious penalties.  No such luck though.  An estimated income tax payment is gone at least until after the end of the year in question.


CCA 201049040

As we discussed, we agree with your conclusion. Lines 3 and 8 of Form 6251 do not apply to taxes incurred in connection with a trade or business. See § 56(b)(1)(A), (b)(1)(D); Reg § 1.62-1T(d)


There is an AMT preference for taxes, but it would not apply, for example, to real estate taxes on Schedule E for a rental property.  I don't think the principle extends to state income taxes attributable to a Schedule C activity.

CCA 201049035

The email responds to your request for assistance. You asked for advice regarding whether there is any limitations period applicable to reducing tax liability based on a net operating loss (NOL) carryback.


Section 6511(a) provides that a “[c]laim for credit or refund of an overpayment . . . shall be filed by the taxpayer within 3 years from the time the return was filed or 2 years from the time the tax was paid, whichever of such periods expires the later.” Section 6511(d)(2) provides an additional special period of limitation with respect to a claim for a refund or credit relating to an overpayment attributable to a NOL carryback. The relevant portion of section 6511(d)(2) provides, in lieu of the 3 year period of limitation prescribed in section 6511(a), the period shall be the period ending 3 years after the due date of the return (plus extensions) for the taxable year of the NOL.


In this case, the Service disallowed the taxpayer's purported claim for credit because it determined that it was untimely. However, you provided that the NOL carryback, if allowed, would not result in an overpayment which would generate a credit or refund but would simply reduce the taxpayer's outstanding tax liability. Even though there are restrictions on the time within which the Service may allow a claim for credit or refund, no such statutory impediments exist to prevent the carryback of an NOL to reduce a taxpayer's outstanding tax liabilities.

This might be of interest to someone dealing with collections who has had things go from bad to worth.  Possibly a carryback from a subsequent disastrous year can alleviate an outstanding debt.

CCA 201049030

 Subject: Filing joint return after filing of substitute for return ————

You asked whether a taxpayer can elect joint status after the Service has filed a substitute for return under section 6020(b) and has issued a notice of deficiency to the taxpayer. The Tax Court held in Millsap v. Commissioner, 91 T.C. 926, 936-937 (1998), acq. in result, AOD-1992-03, that a taxpayer is not foreclosed from electing joint status after the Service has prepared a return under section 6020(b) because the return does not constitute a “separate return” filed by the individual for purposes of section 6013(b). Because the taxpayer has not previously filed a separate return in this case, section 6013(b) does not apply, therefore, the taxpayer may file a joint return provided that none of the exceptions in section 6013(a) apply.

Section 6013(a)(2) states that “in the case of death of one spouse the joint return may be made by the surviving spouse . . . if no return for the taxable year has been made by the decedent, no executor or administrator has been appointed, and no executor or administrator is appointed before the last day prescribed by law for filing the return of the surviving spouse.” The facts that you provided did not state whether an executor or administrator had been appointed. Thus, if an executor or administrator was not appointed, the taxpayer may file a joint return with respect to himself and his deceased spouse. See IRC section 6013(a)(2). 

If you are married and he Service does your return for you it will be married filing separately.  You may be able to reduce the tax if your spouse will consent to a joint return.  If your spouse happens to be dead, you might be able to consent for them.  Definitely has the makings of a Law and Order episode.

Friday, December 10, 2010

And Go Down in Flames

Robert B. McGhee v. Commissioner, TC Memo 2010-259

If you travel the tax blogosphere a bit you will find that many tax bloggers give themselves license to freely comment on many issues.  We know for example that Robert Flach, The Wandering Tax Pro, abhors reality TV, possibly as much as the unreliable software that keeps him preparing returns by hand.  James Edward Maul loves chocolate chip cookies and includes commentary on them as part of Mauled Again's mission statement.  If you look back a bit you will find a couple of non-tax posts in this blog.  Beginning in June, though, I have stuck exclusively to tax.  Most posts are keyed to a specific recent development.  I also generally don't discuss tax policy - (Why is it the way it is ? How could it be better ?).  It is what it is.  Deal with it.

I do, however, find in the tax developments themselves much to ponder beyond the tax problems.  Some opinions have the material for several good novels.  Tax Court Summary opinions, the reality TV of the system, often have the makings of sit com episodes.  Also, they can inspire me to bring in my other passions and interests.  One of these is gender equity.  William Farrel's book is a pretty good read and he makes some good points, although he can lay it on a little thick.  He started out as a feminist giving speeches to men about what bad sexists they were and then had this series of revelations that included things like noticing that although women were clamoring to get into the executive suit as executives rather than secretaries, they did not seem to be rushing into mining and garbage collection, where the relatively high pay is attributable to unpleasant and dangerous working conditions.  I have this image of him showing up in this break room festooned with pin-ups seeking forgiveness and looking to embrace his brother, the garbage collector.  My own particular peculiar view on this matter is summed up in my reaction to the slogan "Another Man Against Violence Against Women".  The implication to this is that it is somehow better for a big strong man to beat up small weak men than it is for him to beat up small weak women.  I think this thought sends a bad message to the people who are most likely to be the victims of violent crime :

Violence against male,blacks, and persons age 24 or younger occurred at higher or somewhat higher rates than the rates of violence against females, whites, and persons 25 or older in 2009.

That's from the Bureau of Justice Statistics.  The message is that even though you are more likely to be a victim, nobody cares. 

I think that just as their is a notion, now much less popular, that an empowered woman is not really a woman, there is an almost symmetrical concept, perhaps more firmly rooted, that a disempowered man is not really a man.  This logic is taken to its extreme in prisons.

At any rate, my passion for gender equity, has left me on the alert for an "innocent spouse" case where it is the guy claiming innocent spouse status.  This is the first one I noticed.  I hate to let facts spoil my preconceived notions, but based an unscientific scanning it's not actually that uncommon.  Mr. McGhee's case is fairly interesting and I probably would have picked up on it regardless of the gender bending. 

Robert McGhee was a commercial airline pilot, who was also active in the Air Force Reserve.  This kept him away from home about 20 days a month.  His wife, Cynthia, worked as a bookkeeper and office manager for a law firm.  At some point she decided to take up a little sideline to bring in some extra money.  She found something that fit in well with her job at the law office.  She started embezzling from them.  Somehow she got caught.  She pleaded no contest and was sentenced to 20 years in prison and 30 years probation.  The sentence was suspended and she was ordered to pay $213,144 of restitution to her former employer, with $60,000 due February 1, 2005, and $2,000 due each month thereafter.

And of course there's the tax issue :

On February 18, 2004, Burch and George mailed Mrs. McGhee Forms 1099-MISC, Miscellaneous Income, reporting nonemployee compensation of $126,772 for 2001 and $117,587 for 2002. These amounts represented the funds that she had embezzled from Burch and George. On November 20, 2004, after the IRS had commenced an audit of petitioner and Mrs. McGhee's 2002 joint return, petitioner and Mrs. McGhee filed amended joint Federal income tax returns for 2001 and 2002, reporting as income the embezzlement proceeds reported on the Forms 1099-MISC. The 2001 amended return reflects additional tax of $40,366 and a balance due of $40,366. The 2002 amended return reflects additional tax of $33,920 and a balance due of $35,399. Respondent accepted the amended joint returns, processed them, and on February 7, 2005, assessed the tax stated on them. Neither petitioner nor Mrs. McGhee paid the balances due on the amended returns.

I can't figure out what the point of the 1099's was. Under general principles, the embezzled funds were gross income to Mrs. McGhee.  I just don't see what her employer was up to in sending the forms.  I don't know under what theory they are required or what they thought they were accomplishing.

Regardless it was the fellow who spent his spare time serving his country rather than stealing from his employer who thought the IRS might find him an innocent spouse.  No such luck.  So he tried the Tax Court.  The Court went through the same eight factors we discussed in the case of Eileen Pugsley :

(1) is separated or divorced from the nonrequesting spouse,
(2) had knowledge or reason to know that the nonrequesting spouse would not pay the income tax liability,
(3) would suffer economic hardship if relief were denied,
(4) complied with income tax laws in years after the year at issue,
(5) received significant economic benefit from the unpaid income tax liability,
(6) was abused by the nonrequesting spouse,
(7) was in poor health when signing the return or requesting relief,
(8) whether the nonrequesting spouse had a legal obligation to pay the outstanding tax

For some reason the judge in this case ordered them differently.  Regardless, the couple had remained married, Mrs. McGhee was not abusive and Mr. McGhee had always had good health making four of the eight factors (1,6,7, and 8 in this list) neutral.

Mr. McGhee had complied with the income tax laws at all times after this mess started giving him one factor in his favor.  The IRS concedes that having to pay the deficiency would cause severe economic hardship for Mr.McGhee.  Remember they have to pay the money back or Mrs.McGhee goes to prison.  The pay back should be deductible and there is a special "claim of right" computation, but that probably isn't going to help that much.

Here's where things get a little crazy.  Mr.McGhee had no idea as to what happened to the embezzled money.  Mrs.McGhee, the embezzler, said it went for general family support.  In the court Mr.McGhee had the burden of proving that he didn't benefit from the embezzled funds, a burden he did not carry.  There did not seem to be any evidence that Mr.McGhee knew his wife was embezzling.  He was away as much as 20 days a month.  I don't know.  Doesn't seem right.

The knowledge one is where it gets really crazy.  The IRS argues that his knowledge should be evaluated at the point in time when he signed the amended return.  The tax court has twice ruled against the IRS on this issue, but they are not giving up.  They decided, however, that they don't need to argue about it with the IRS.  When the original 2002 return was filed, Mrs. McGhee had already been caught.  They figured that all the extra money floating around should have tipped Mr. McGhee off to something being up when he signed the 2001 return.
Final score was as follows:

As indicated by the foregoing analysis, four factors are neutral. Two of the factors—compliance with Federal tax laws and economic hardship—favor relief. Two of the factors— significant benefit and knowledge—weigh against relief. Thus, as respondent acknowledges, a “strictly mathematical balancing of the factors shows them to be in equipoise”. If we were to conclude on this score that there is an evidentiary tie.. .......... But rather than decide this case on that basis, we conclude on a preponderance of all the evidence that petitioner is not entitled to equitable relief. In reaching this conclusion, we take into account petitioner's lack of credibility on several key points as well as his seeming lack of good faith in waiting until after the IRS had opened an audit on his 2002 tax year to file amended joint returns reflecting the embezzlement proceeds that he had, at that point, long known about but had not previously reported.

In a previous post I quoted Dr. Johnson's remark that "Every man thinks meanly of himself for not having been a soldier, or not having been at sea" which motivates me to throw my stubborn ounces on the scale that is in equipoise.  Mr. McGhee used his spare time to serve his country.  The evidence that he benefited from embezzled funds was the testimony of the embezzler.  If he had divorced her he would have had another point in his favor, but he didn't do that.  I can't say his gender counted against him.  Women also lose innocent spouse cases, which is why I have so many blog posts on the unrecognized hazards of joint returns.  Regardless, I think he got a raw deal.

It could be worse.  Consider the plight of Robert Thomas, an Australian resident of Saudi Arabia.  His wife was convicted of embezzling and he got 16 months in prison and 300 lashes (in convenient installments of 50 each).  Under Sharia law there is no such thing as a male innocent spouse.
























.


http://www.abc.net.au/worldtoday/content/s805498.htm

Friday, November 26, 2010

Think Before Filing Joint Returns

Eileen L. Pugsley v. Commissioner, TC Memo 2010-255

I've written before on not reflexively filing joint returns.  This case may be a particularly good illustration of the point.  It is also one of those stories that illustrates the point that tax problems are frequently the tip of the iceberg of more serious problems.  Eileen Pugsley put up with a lot before she divorced her dentist husband, Daniel.  She was asking the tax court if she has to put up with being saddled with 6 years worth of unpaid tax liabilities.  The tax court indicated that she will.

Doctor Pugsley had been on a long slide due to alcoholism.  In 2005, he lost his dental license, because of failure to fulfill his CPE requirement.  He continued to practice without a license until 2007 when his practice was shut down by the Ohio State Dental Board.   He continued dressing for work and leaving the house each day, but spent the day drinking. 

Finally he entered a rehabilitation program.  While he was there Mrs. Pugsley found unfiled joint tax returns for the years 1999 to 2003 in a dresser drawer.  She called the family accountant who advised her to file them right away.  Prior to filing the returns she applied for innocent spouse relief.  The IRS turned her down because the returns hadn't been filed.  Several months later the returns were filed.  She applied again for innocent spouse relief and was denied again.  The factors considered were as follow:

(1) is separated or divorced from the nonrequesting spouse,
(2) had knowledge or reason to know that the nonrequesting spouse would not pay the income tax liability,
 (3) would suffer economic hardship if relief were denied,
(4) complied with income tax laws in years after the year at issue,
(5) received significant economic benefit from the unpaid income tax liability,
 (6) was abused by the nonrequesting spouse,
(7) was in poor health when signing the return or requesting relief,
(8) whether the nonrequesting spouse had a legal obligation to pay the outstanding

The first factor that she was divorced when filing with the tax court was the only factor in her favor.  The second factor weighed against her since she should have known that her husband was not capable of paying the tax.  The third factor weighed against her :

Petitioner receives $58,000 per year in salary, $1,500 in monthly spousal support, $484.17 in monthly marital asset payments and $240 per month for health insurance payments for her children. Petitioner testified that her monthly expenses are minimal. Petitioner has no dependents though she provides some financial support to her youngest child. Respondent determined that, based on petitioner's spousal support and salary, petitioner had monthly disposable income of $461 that could be applied to the tax liabilities.

The fourth factor also weighed against her :

Respondent's Appeals Office determined that petitioner was compliant with tax laws as of 2008. Petitioner failed, however, to report spousal alimony as taxable income after her separation agreement was executed in September 2009. She also claimed a $5,000 deduction for contributing to an IRA but failed to make the requisite contribution. She alleges to have filed an amended return only after the issue was brought to her attorney's attention, though no amended return was submitted into evidence.

She also lost on the fifth factor, although I have a little trouble understanding this one:

Petitioner spent $300 a month to belong to a tony athletic club and purchased a home for over $500,000. Petitioner also sent her children to expensive private colleges. The facts and circumstances presented strongly suggest that petitioner received a significant benefit from the failure to pay the tax liabilities. This factor also weighs against relief.

I mean what is so great about having Tony in your health club ?

The remaining factors were neutral.  She tried to argue that Dr. Pugsley's financial irresponsibility constituted abuse, but that isn't the type of abuse they mean.  The Court found his agreement under the divorce decree to pay the taxes of no account since he clearly couldn't pay them in full.  He was paying the IRS $1,000 per month.

The final score was 1 favorable factor, 4 unfavorable and 3 neutral.  So Mrs. Pugsley has to keep paying the IRS monthly on the debt her husband is responsible for according to the divorce decree.

I don't have all the facts, but I am going to go out on a limb here.  I believe it is likely that the decision to file joint returns was a mistake.  If I had gotten the panicked call from Mrs. Pugsley, I would certainly not have told her to just go ahead and file the returns.  There is a good chance that I would have concluded that she should have sent in Married Filing Separate returns even if they were not required.  (This is because a non-signing spouse can be deemed to have consented to a joint return, an issue I previously discussed.)

The problem is that there are really two fairly distinct areas of tax practice.  The one that is most familiar and where I spend most of my time involves determining the correct tax and planning the legitimate ways of minimizing it.  Included in this is elections such as the election to file a joint return.  The other area is collection.  In collection matters, the correct amount of the tax is often only of academic interest, if that.  What is important in this area is how much they think they can get from you and whether you are acting like a good doobie.  Presumably if Dr. Pugsley had filed separately his correct tax would be even higher.  However, the benefit of joint filing reduced the tax to an amount that was still higher than what he could conceivably pay.  There is a sense in which all tax amounts that can never be fully paid are equal.  The joint filing created another source that IRS could collect from namely Mrs. Pugsley's post divorce salary.

It may be that I am being unfair to Mrs. Pugsley's advisers.  They may have duly considered separate filing and rejected it for some reason that does not appear in the record of the case.  I have practiced enough in this area to know, however, that the decision to file jointly is often made reflexively or is just viewed in terms of tax minimizing.  Requesting innocent spouse relief on unfiled returns indicates that there was a fundamental misunderstanding of the two different systems.