Showing posts with label medical expense. Show all posts
Showing posts with label medical expense. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Donee Gets Income Tax Deductions for Medical Expenses and Taxes

Judith F. Lang v. Commissioner, TC Memo 2010-286

From time to time I encounter confused people.  They might for example think that they can give $13,000 to each of their kids and deduct it.  That's not the way it works.  The $13,000 is the amount that you can give to as many individuals as you want to - including me by the way (I'll tell you where to mail the check) - without having a taxable gift (Under the new regime, you can have $5,000,000 in taxable gifts before you have to start paying gift tax).  Gift tax is the responsibility of the person making the gift.  Income tax is the responsibility of the person receiving taxable income, which does not include gifts.  So what happens if your aunt gives you $10,000,000 of low basis stock, but wants you to pay the gift tax for her ?  You and your aunt can give me a call and I'll work with you on it.  This post is about something that happens with the merely wealthy.

The annual exclusion is not the only exclusion from gift tax.  There is also an exclusion for gifts made for medical or educational purposes.  In order to qualify for the exclusion the donor must pay the bills directly.  So if you pay the medical bills of your adult children those payments are excluded for gift tax purposes (i.e. You can give the ne'er do wells who can't pay their own medical bills $13,000 in cash on top of that without eating into your $5,000,000.  They'll still probably resent you, but you'll need to find another blog to deal with those issues.)

Medical expenses are also deductible for income tax purposes, though.  What is supposed to happen for income tax purposes when your medical bills are paid by someone else ? Judith Lang had some heavy medical expenses and was behind on her real estate taxes.  Fortunately, she had a generous Mom :

Petitioner's mother, Frances Field (Mrs. Field), paid $24,559 directly to medical providers on account of petitioner's medical expenses and paid $5,508 directly to the city government on account of petitioner's real estate tax. Petitioner was not a minor, and Mrs. Field was not legally obligated to pay petitioner's expenses.


Ms. Lang thought that she should be able to deduct these payments for income tax purposes:

It is petitioner's position that although Mrs. Field made the payments directly to petitioner's creditors, we should consider them to have in substance passed from Mrs. Field to petitioner and then to petitioner's creditors; therefore petitioner should be entitled to deduct the payments.

The IRS did not agree:

Respondent contends that the form of the transaction should apply and that because the money was paid directly from Mrs. Field to petitioner's creditors, petitioner may not claim the deductions.

The Tax Court noted that the IRS did not claim that Ms. Fields had deducted the medical expenses only that Ms. Lang was precluded from deducting them because she had not paid them.

The Tax Court ruled in favor of the taxpayer with respect to both the medical expenses and the real estate taxes.  With respect to the medical expenses they noted:

Although Mrs. Field and petitioner would not be subject to the gift tax,  the income tax treatment in this context is not controlled by the gift tax consequence.

Petitioner should be credited with having made the payments for purposes of the income tax deduction in question.



With respect to the real estate taxes the issue was even clearer:

Mrs. Field paid $5,508 directly to the city government in discharge of petitioner's obligation for real estate tax. Again applying substance over form, we treat petitioner as having received from her mother a gift of the $5,508 with which petitioner paid the city in satisfaction of her own real estate tax. Thus petitioner is entitled to a deduction under section 164 for that amount.


We note that there is no danger of a “double deduction” arising from our decision on this issue. See Rome I, Ltd. v. Commissioner, 96 T.C. 697, 704 (1991) (”Double deductions are impermissible *** absent a clear declaration of intent of Congress.”). Because the real estate tax was imposed upon petitioner, she is the only taxpayer who may deduct it; Mrs. Field may not. See sec. 1.164-1(a), Income Tax Regs.

This is a significant decision for some wealthy families where transfer tax concerns outweigh income tax concerns.  It would be a good idea to review the individual returns of family members who have benefited from gift tax excludable medical gifts.

Friday, February 11, 2011

From Mercenaries to Mothers Milk

Announcement 2011-14

As yesterdays post compared with todays shows tax issues cover the gamut of human phenomena.  I don't make this stuff up though.  There is obviously selection on my part, but I work with the material that is thrown at me.

Normally I don't post on things that I pick up from other blogs.  I review original source material for items of interest either because of practical importance, humour or opportunity for reflection.  This particular item hit the news more quickly because a bunch of legislators are patting themselves on the back for persuading the IRS into reversing its position. To give credit where it is due, I first noticed this in Accounting and Tax Tips.  Although he didn't give a citation.  I found that in Accounting Today along with a link to the full text.  This is one of those very rare occasions where something gets into the blogosphere before it gets into Checkpoint.

The announcement which I reproduce below indicates that breast pumps and related supplies are deductible as medical expenses. Possibly of more practical significance it also makes them reimbursable under flexible spending arrangements.

The Internal Revenue Service has concluded that breast pumps and supplies that assist lactation are medical care under § 213(d) of the Internal Revenue Code because, like obstetric care, they are for the purpose of affecting a structure or function of the body of the lactating woman. Therefore, if the remaining requirements of § 213(a) are met (for example, the taxpayer’s total medical expenses exceed 7.5 percent of adjusted gross income), expenses paid for breast pumps and supplies that assist lactation are deductible medical expenses. Amounts reimbursed for these expenses under flexible spending arrangements, Archer medical savings accounts, health reimbursement arrangements, or health savings accounts are not income to the taxpayer.
The Service will revise Publication 502, Medical and Dental Expenses, to include this
information.


In INFO 2010-0173, the IRS had reached the opposite conclusion :

I am responding your letter of March 30, 2009, to Commissioner Douglas H. Schulman about the treatment of costs associated with breast pumps and related equipment. You recommend that the Service allow the costs of breast pumps and related equipment to be reimbursable under a tax favored health care flexible spending account (FSA).

In general, funds from an FSA are to be used for medical care. The Internal Revenue Code defines medical care to include the diagnosis, cure, mitigation, treatment or prevention of disease. Medical care includes medicine and drugs, but does not include goods or services that are merely beneficial to general health and do not mitigate or treat a disease. Under current law, therefore, the cost of purchasing or renting a breast pump and related equipment would not come within the definition of a medical care expense for FSA purposes, even though the mother's usage of the breast pump may have the health benefits mentioned in your letter.

It is not within the authority of the Internal Revenue Service to classify breastfeeding equipment as medical care in contravention of current law. A change to the Internal Revenue Code must be made by Congress.

Since "everybody else" is writing about this, I would normally pass it by except that one of my earliest blog posts was on a lactation issue that I thought the IRS had gotten wrong.  It had a very clever title, so you should click the link just to find out.  The IRS had disallowed a deduction for infant formula by a woman who had had a double mastectomy.  So the tax geek response to the stories about this announcement is "Well does that mean the Service will revisit its holding in PLR 200941003 ?"

Monday, January 11, 2010

IRS Lactation Intolerant


PLR 200941003


Somebody once told me about a tax attorney who was presented with a question that he found extremely interesting. His comment was “That is an extremely interesting question. I hope we will have a client situation that it bears on it so I will be able to research it.” For better or worse I lack that discipline and will go poking around at things that will be of little or no practical benefit. It happens that about the most, to me, intriguing ruling of 2009 falls into that category.

PLR 200941003 was about the deductibility of infant formula as a medical expense. Citing Revenue Ruling 55-261, the service held that the formula was not deductible; the reasoning was that the formula just provided for normal nutrition. I think the ruling is wrong and the basis that they used indicates that they missed the point of the ruling request. The ruling request was on the behalf of not, the presumably well-fed, infant, but rather on behalf of the mother, who as it happens, had had a double mastectomy.

The definition of a deductible medical expense is fairly broad. It includes not only diagnosis, treatment and prevention, but also mitigation. Included in the last, for example, would be the cost of a special school. PLR 200318017 allowed a deduction for the various expenses involved in arranging for an egg donation for a woman unable to conceive using her own eggs.

What I find really curious, though, is why the ruling was requested in the first place. I did some, admittedly cursory, research which leads me to believe that the dollars involved cannot possibly be substantial. The furthest out estimate for annual cost of infant formula that I found was around $3,000. $1,200 would be a more representative estimate. Regardless you are not talking much north of $1,000 in tax probably somewhat less. Furthermore, it is not as if the deal will rise or fall based on the tax answer. Conceivably you might scuttle a merger if you can’t get a favorable ruling, but it is pretty clear that deductible or not the formula will be purchased.
It would seem to be a little silly to pay for a ruling request that you might think was frivolous, so why not just take the deduction and disclose?

The only thing I could think of was to create some stir on the issue. I couldn’t find that the ruling generated much other interest though.


Oh by the way :


Any tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein.