Monday, November 29, 2010

IRS To Stop Lousing Up Short Sales

PMTA 2010-058

For the latest on this see my follow-up post

When I was a kid, my father worked on Wall Street.  He was a Senior Order Clerk.  I'm not sure whether his job still exists.  It was not particularly lucrative, but I got these insights into high finance through the jokes that he used to tell me.  Most of them I didn't "get" until I was in my thirties.  One of my favorites is the little ditty "He who sells what isn't hissen, buys it back or goes to prison."  That was about short sales as the term relates to securities. 

The term means something else in real estate.  If a property has a fair market value lesser than the mortgage, the secured party might let the property be sold for an amount lesser than the mortgage.  This avoids the need for foreclosure.  The owner may or may not remain liable for the balance, the discharge of which may or may not be a taxable event.  Such is not the topic of this post.

When I was buying a condo, I found that buying property on a short sale tended to be fraught with delay.  You would think that the pressure to sell would create pressure to move things along, but the pressure is not sufficient to overcome bureaucratic inertia.  Not surprisingly people who have trouble paying their mortgages frequently have trouble paying their taxes.  So it is not unusual for a property with an upside down mortgage to have IRS liens against it.  In order for the property to transfer the IRS must release its lien.

Typically the first mortgage will have been in place before the IRS filed its liens.  So the value of the lien is the lesser of the tax obligation or the taxpayers equity in the property.  In the case of a short sale the latter amount is 0.  So the IRS should release its worthless lien and let life go on.  That is not what has happened though.  Even though the IRS is behind the first mortgage, they are, or at least, believe they are ahead of everybody else :

Applications for Discharge Which Include Requests for Payment of Real Estate Transfer Tax....In cases where a filed notice of federal tax lien has perfected the interest of the United States in such property, the Service is asked to issue a certificate of discharge of federal tax lien to allow payment of the state's claim at closing. It is the Service's position that such taxes have no priority status under I.R.C. §6323(b)(6) against the filed notice of federal tax lien. ... Priority of the federal tax lien is defined exclusively in I.R.C. §6323. Under no circumstances will a discharge of federal tax lien be issued for less than the full value of the Service's claim on the equity in the subject property. The transfer tax will not be accorded priority status or treated as an expense of sale. Applications that include such provisions will be rejected.

Under this interpretation, the taxpayer/property owner has to come up with the transfer taxes in order to move the transaction on.


PMTA 2010-058 finds the above interpretation to be erroneous:

We disagree with the conclusion that the designation by the senior lienholder of some of its proceeds to be used to pay real estate transfer taxes in connection with short sales of real property somehow creates an equity interest in the property on the part of the taxpayer. Rather, these are expenses that the senior lienholder agrees to carve out of its priority lien claim as a matter of business prudence in order to facilitate the sale. Because this does not create an equity interest on behalf of the taxpayer that is subject to the federal tax lien, the authority of the Service to issue a certificate of discharge is under section 6325(b)(2)(B), where the interest in the United States is valueless. The Service has no authority under section 6325(b)(2)(B) to require payment of the sum that otherwise would be applied to junior real estate transfer taxes as a condition of discharge. Because the interest of the United States is valueless, the result would be the same even if the senior lienholder was choosing to use a portion of its mortgage proceeds to pay a junior creditor of the taxpayer (such as payment of homeowner's association fees).

Essentially they are saying that the carve-out for transfer taxes is coming out of the banks secured interest and does not create some sort of equity that makes the IRS lien worth something.  This document a letter to the director of collection policy (PMTA stands for Program Manager Technical Assistance) was dated September 17, 2010, but only recently came up on RIA.  I haven't seen anything else on this so I am making this a bonus post in the interest of timeliness. If you are involved in a short sale that is hanging because of the IRS, it might be a useful reference.

The letter was sent to the Director of Collection Policy for Small Business/ Self Employed.  It was copied to Special Counsel of the National Taxpayer Advocate Program, Assistant Division Counsel (SBSE) and Associate Area Counsels for Ft. Lauderdale and Jacksonville.  So this may be a problem that is peculiar to Florida although the principle is of general interest.

P.S.
In the comments below you will see feedback from Richard Zaretsky, an attorney specializing in short sales and related matters.  He indicated to me that he has had shouting matches with the IRS on this issue.  He has a blog dedicated to short sales.  I've seen some misinformation on websites that would lead you to believe that an IRS lien will kill the possibility of a short sale.  The relevant section of the Code is 6325(b)(2)(B) which indicates a lien with no value can be released and that in determining the lien's value other liens with priority will be taken into account.

11 comments:

  1. Excellent article I have a friend who has this situation where he has a short sale ready to go but he has to deal with the federal tax lien. I recommend getting the Tax Payer Advocate involved when the IRS refuses to lift its lien based on the hardship it causes the taxpayer in getting out from under the property and the fact that the IRS is entitled to nothing since the property is upside down.

    Mark Stanhope

    ReplyDelete
  2. Precisely the problem we have had in the past, which position made absolutely no sense. Great post.

    Richard Zaretsky, Esq.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You made a few fine points there. I did a search on the matter and found a good number of folks will go along with with your blog.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Aweѕome! Іts truly awesome pоst, I have got much clear іdea concernіng from
    this pіece of wгiting.
    My page > ryanspaydayloans.co.uk

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hello There. I found your blog uѕing msn. This іs an ехtгemely
    ωell ωritten article. I'll make sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful info. Thanks for the post. I'll definitely return.
    Also visit my page loans for bad credit

    ReplyDelete
  6. Αpрreсiatе thіs pоst.
    Will try it out.
    My site how to stop snoring nhs

    ReplyDelete
  7. We're a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community. Your web site provided us with valuable info to work on. You'ѵe done an imprеѕsіvе jоb and our entіre community will be thаnκful to yοu.


    my blog - New Bingo Sites
    My page: New Bingo Sites

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hello collеagues, hoω іs all, anԁ what yοu ωish
    fοr to ѕаy conceгnіng this post, in my viеw іts tгulу аmazing
    dеsigned for me.

    my site :: payday loans bad credit

    ReplyDelete
  9. I loved аs muсh as you'll receive carried out right here. The sketch is tasteful, your authored material stylish. nonetheless, you command get bought an edginess over that you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come further formerly again since exactly the same nearly a lot often inside case you shield this hike.

    My web site - payday loans
    my site: payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  10. Vеry gоoԁ infο. Lucky mе
    I came aсroѕs youг ѕitе by
    сhanсe (ѕtumblеupon).

    I've bookmarked it for later!

    Here is my web blog ... payday

    ReplyDelete
  11. I all the time used to study рοst in newѕ papers but now as
    I am a user of internet thus frοm now I аm
    using net foг posts, thanks tо web.


    Here is my website ... payday loans

    ReplyDelete